+1 (347) 918-4030

Denial codes in medical billing explained, including CO, PR, OA, and PI group codes.

Denial Codes in Medical Billing: CO, PR, OA & PI Explained

Last Updated: November 17, 2026
[hm_blog_dates]

Your practice submits a claim, but when the payment comes back, the amount is lower than expected. Sometimes there’s no payment at all. You open the remittance advice and find codes like CO-16, PR-96, or OA-23.

Now you need to figure out what happened. Was the claim denied? Does the patient owe anything? Should you correct the claim or contact the insurance company?

Denial codes in medical billing tell you why an insurer adjusted a claim and help you determine what to do next. In this guide, we’ll explain denial codes in medical billing, what CO, PR, OA, and PI mean, and how to handle the codes your billing team commonly encounters.

What Are Denial Codes in Medical Billing?

Denial codes are standardized alphanumeric codes that insurance companies use to explain why a claim was denied or why its payment was reduced .

They appear on remittance advice and help billing teams identify problems such as missing information, duplicate claims, expired coverage, or services that don’t meet the payer’s coverage requirements.

For example, CO-29 tells you the filing deadline has passed, while CO-97 indicates that payment for a service is included in another service’s payment.

However, not every claim adjustment is a denial.

For example, your practice bills $200 for a service, but the insurance company allows $150 under its contracted rate. The remaining $50 is reported as a contractual adjustment under CO-45.

The claim has been successfully processed and approved for payment. No denial resolution or appeal is needed.

There’s also a difference between a claim rejection and a denial.

Claim rejection: The claim fails an initial check, often because of missing or invalid information, and is returned without processing.

Claim denial: The payer processes the claim but determines that payment shouldn’t be made for the claim or service.

A rejected claim generally needs its submission error fixed, while a denial may require correction, additional documentation, reconsideration, or an appeal.

Further reading: Medical Claims in Billing: Process, Types & Steps

How Medical Billing Denial Codes Work

An insurance company sends a remittance advice (RA), either electronically or on paper, once it processes a claim. This advice contains standardized codes that explain why the claim was denied or its payment was adjusted and who’s financially responsible for the adjusted amount.

Understanding the Structure of Denial Codes

A code such as CO-16 has two parts: a group code and a Claim Adjustment Reason Code (CARC). Some adjustments also include a Remittance Advice Remark Code (RARC) that provides more detail.

Code ComponentWhat It Tells You
Group CodeIdentifies the adjustment category and helps establish financial responsibility. Examples include CO, PR, OA, and PI.
CARCClaim Adjustment Reason Code. Explains why a claim or specific service line was paid differently from the billed amount.
RARCRemittance Advice Remark Code. Provides additional information about the adjustment or remittance processing.

Take CO-16, for example.

The letters CO (Contractual Obligation) put financial responsibility for the adjustment on the practitioner, while 16 indicates missing information or a claim submission error.

However, CO-16 alone doesn’t tell you exactly what the problem is. You’ll need to check the RARC included in the remittance advice to find out what went wrong.

The official X12 Claim Adjustment Reason Codes list provides current definitions and usage requirements.

Where to Find Denial Codes on an ERA or EOB

When reviewing a remittance, here’s what you need to check:

  1. Claim or service-line details: Find out which claim or service was adjusted.
  2. Billed and allowed amounts: Check how much you billed and how much the insurance company allowed.
  3. Payment and adjustment amounts: See how much was paid, adjusted, or left for the patient.
  4. Group code, CARC, and RARC: Read these codes together to understand why the payment was adjusted or denied.

Don’t assume a single claim will have only one adjustment. For example, a claim may come back with CO-45 for the contractual write-off and PR-2 showing how much the patient owes in coinsurance.

As a billing manager, you need to make sure each adjustment is recorded correctly.

CO vs. PR vs. OA vs. PI: What’s the Difference?

The four claim adjustment groups used in current healthcare remittances are CO, PR, OA, and PI.

Each group helps explain the nature of the adjustment and its financial responsibility.

Group CodeMeaningFinancial Responsibility / Billing Implication
COContractual ObligationGenerally the provider’s responsibility and not billable to the patient.
PRPatient ResponsibilityAn amount assigned to the patient, subject to coverage terms and applicable billing rules.
OAOther AdjustmentUsed when no other group applies. Requires review of the reason code and claim context.
PIPayer-Initiated ReductionA payer-directed reduction that is not the patient’s responsibility and lacks a supporting contractual basis.

CO – Contractual Obligation

CO codes tell you when an insurance company reduces or denies payment based on contractual or regulatory requirements.

For example, CO-45 means the billed amount is higher than the fee schedule or allowed amount. The difference is generally written off by the provider and cannot be billed to the patient.

However, not every CO adjustment means you should write off the amount. Some codes, such as CO-16, indicate claim errors that need to be reviewed and corrected before you close the account.

PR – Patient Responsibility

PR codes show how much the patient is responsible for paying, such as deductibles, copays, and coinsurance.

For example, PR-2 indicates the amount the patient owes in coinsurance.

But before sending a patient bill, make sure you’ve checked for secondary insurance and confirmed that the balance can actually be billed to the patient.

This is an important part of patient billing services. Your billing team needs to make sure the patient is being billed for the right amount, not for something their insurance should cover.

OA – Other Adjustment

OA codes are used for adjustments that don’t fall under the other group codes.

For example, OA-23 shows how a previous payer’s payment or adjustments affect the current claim. You’ll usually see this when handling coordination of benefits (COB), especially when a patient has both primary and secondary insurance.

When you see OA-23, check how the previous insurer processed the claim before treating the amount as a denial or transferring it to the patient’s balance.

PI – Payer-Initiated Reduction

PI codes indicate that the insurance company has reduced the payment without a supporting contractual basis. The adjusted amount isn’t the patient’s responsibility.

If you come across a PI adjustment, check the payer’s reason against its payment policies and the claim documentation.

Don’t write off the amount or bill the patient right away. First, find out whether the reduction is correct or needs to be disputed with the payer.

Common Denial Codes in Medical Billing and Their Meanings

The following claim denial code list covers frequently encountered CO, PR, OA, and PI adjustments.

Use the tables to identify what each code means and what your billing team should check before taking action.

Common CO Denial Codes

CO codes often involve coverage problems, claim errors, contractual adjustments, or payment rules.

CodeWhat It MeansWhat to Check or Do
CO-16Missing information or a billing/submission errorRead the accompanying RARC and correct the identified issue.
CO-22Another payer may be responsible under COB rulesVerify primary and secondary insurance order.
CO-27Expenses were incurred after coverage endedCheck eligibility and coverage dates.
CO-29Timely filing deadline expiredReview submission dates, payer limits, and proof of timely filing.
CO-45Charge exceeds the applicable fee schedule or allowed amountVerify the contracted rate before posting the adjustment.
CO-50Service wasn’t considered medically necessaryReview the payer’s medical policy and supporting clinical records.
CO-96Noncovered chargeRead the required remark code and check the coverage policy.
CO-97Payment is included in another adjudicated serviceReview bundling rules, coding edits, and modifiers.
CO-109Claim belongs with another payer or contractorIdentify the correct payer and filing requirements.
CO-204Service, equipment, or drug isn’t covered by the current benefit planVerify the patient’s specific benefits and exclusions.
CO-210Authorization or precertification wasn’t received in timeCompare authorization dates with the payer’s requirements.
CO-252Additional documentation or an attachment is requiredUse the accompanying remark code to identify what’s needed.
CO-253Federal payment reduction due to sequestrationVerify and post the applicable federal payment adjustment.

Two distinctions are worth keeping in mind.

For CO-97, don’t automatically add a modifier to get the claim paid. First, confirm that documentation supports separate billing.

And CO-253 is a federal payment adjustment, not a routine claim denial requiring correction or appeal.

Further reading: CO-210 Denial Code Explained: Causes, Fixes & Prevention

Common PR Denial Codes

PR adjustments can affect patient balances, but the group code alone doesn’t establish that collection is appropriate.

CodeWhat It MeansWhat to Check or Do
PR-1Deductible amountVerify the deductible and any secondary coverage.
PR-2Coinsurance amountCheck the patient’s share of the allowed amount.
PR-3Copayment amountConfirm the copay and any amount already collected.
PR-27Expenses after coverage terminatedVerify eligibility before assigning the balance to the patient.
PR-31Patient couldn’t be identified as insuredCheck subscriber details and payer records.
PR-96Noncovered chargesRead the remark code and confirm whether patient billing is permitted.
PR-119Benefit maximum reached for the period or occurrenceCheck benefit limits and previous utilization.
PR-177Patient hasn’t met required eligibility conditionsVerify the unmet requirements with the payer.
PR-204Service isn’t covered by the patient’s benefit planCheck the benefit exclusion and applicable patient liability rules.
PR-227Information requested from the patient or responsible party was missing or incompleteReview the accompanying remark code and obtain the information.
PR-242Service wasn’t provided by a network or designated primary care providerVerify network restrictions and patient protections.

Be particularly careful with PR-96, PR-204, and PR-242. A noncovered or out-of-network service doesn’t automatically mean the patient can legally be billed for the entire amount.

Common OA Denial Codes

OA adjustments often require a closer look at previous claim processing.

CodeWhat It MeansWhat to Check or Do
OA-18Exact duplicate claim or serviceCompare the claim with previously processed submissions.
OA-23Impact of a previous payer’s payments or adjustmentsReview the primary payer’s remittance and COB details.
OA-136Prior payer’s coverage rules weren’t followedReview the earlier payer’s requirements and decision.
OA-22Another payer may be responsible for the serviceCheck the insurance order and payer-specific COB instructions.

OA-18 and OA-23 mean different things.

OA-18 identifies an exact duplicate claim or service. OA-23 reflects previous payer adjudication.

Under X12 rules, CARC 23 is used with OA. CARC 18 is also restricted to OA, except where certain state workers’ compensation regulations require CO.

Common PI Denial Codes

PI adjustments are less familiar to some billing teams, but they still need attention when a payer reduces an expected payment.

CodeWhat It MeansWhat to Check or Do
PI-16Missing information or a submission errorReview the accompanying RARC and verify the payer’s findings.
PI-22Another payer may be responsibleConfirm COB information and the payer’s reason for the reduction.
PI-96Charge isn’t coveredReview the required remark code and applicable coverage policy.
PI-97Service payment is included in another serviceCheck bundling rules and the related adjudicated service.
PI-252Supporting documentation is requiredRead the remark code and supply the necessary documentation.

Some CARC numbers appear with more than one group code, although certain combinations are restricted by X12.

For example, CO-16 and PI-16 share reason code 16, but the group code changes the adjustment classification.

That’s why it’s important to read the complete code combination before deciding what to do.

How to Read Denial Codes: Real Medical Billing Examples

Let’s look at two situations that show how adjustment codes affect payment posting and claim follow-up.

Example 1: CO-45 and PR-2 on a Partially Paid Claim

Your practice bills $200 for an office visit. The insurance company allows $150 under your contract and assigns $30 in coinsurance to the patient.

Here’s how the payment breaks down:

Claim DetailAmountWhat It Means
Billed amount$200Your original charge
Allowed amount$150Payer’s approved amount
CO-45 adjustment$50Contractual reduction
PR-2 adjustment$30Patient coinsurance
Insurance payment$120Amount paid by the insurer

The payer pays $120, your practice adjusts $50 as a contractual write-off, and $30 remains as patient responsibility.

The claim wasn’t denied. It was processed and paid according to the plan’s payment terms.

Before sending a patient statement, check whether secondary insurance applies and whether the patient has already paid anything toward the coinsurance.

Example 2: CO-22 vs. OA-23 in Coordination of Benefits

A patient has two insurance plans, but the claim reaches the secondary payer before the primary payer’s information has been properly recorded.

The secondary payer may return CO-22, indicating that another insurer could be responsible.

Your first step is to verify the patient’s insurance order. If the claim went to the wrong payer, correct the billing sequence.

Now suppose the primary payer has already processed the claim, and the secondary payer receives those payment details.

The secondary remittance may show OA-23, reflecting the impact of the primary payer’s payment or adjustments.

Here’s the difference: CO-22 points toward a possible payer-order problem. OA-23 reflects prior-payer adjudication and doesn’t necessarily mean anything went wrong.

Review both remittances before determining what remains payable or collectible.

How to Handle Denial Codes in Medical Billing

Effective denial management means identifying denied claims, resolving them correctly, and fixing the problems that cause repeat denials.

The American Medical Association (AMA) recommends reviewing denial patterns, improving billing workflows, and tracking results.

A2Z Medical Billing Services uses a five-step denial management process built around these principles. Billing managers can use it to organize their denial queues, assign work, and monitor whether their team’s corrections are working.

A2Z’s Five-Step Denial Management Workflow

Five practical checkpoints for billing managers reviewing denied claims.

01

Spot & Prioritize

Which claims need attention first?

Identify denied claims from ERA reports. Prioritize those approaching filing or appeal deadlines and those with significant recoverable balances.

02

Triage & Classification

What type of denial is it, and who should handle it?

Read the CARC, RARC, and payer explanation. Classify the issue as technical (claim errors), clinical (medical necessity or documentation), or administrative (eligibility, authorization, or insurance order). Route it to the appropriate team member.

03

Root Cause Analysis

Is this an isolated error or a recurring problem?

Check whether the issue affects one claim, one provider, or several claims. Identify where the error started and assign someone to address it.

04

Appeal & Recovery

What’s the correct action to recover payment?

Follow the payer’s requirements for correcting, resubmitting, reconsidering, or appealing the claim. Track deadlines and follow up until the payer responds. Don’t automatically resubmit a denied claim.

05

Prevention

Did the changes reduce repeat denials?

Fix the underlying issue through coding reviews, staff training, or process improvements. Compare denial rates for the same code, payer, or provider before and after the correction.

Important Medicare Denial Rules

One important exception when choosing the next action is Original Medicare.

If a claim is returned as unprocessable with CARC 16 and RARC MA130, you generally need to fix the error and submit a new claim rather than appeal the return.

An adjudicated Medicare denial, however, may qualify for redetermination. The first-level appeal deadline is generally 120 days from receiving the initial determination notice.

Check the CMS Medicare redetermination guidance for the applicable requirements.

A2Z’s Workflow in Practice

How do you know your denial management process is working?

Look for fewer billing errors, fewer repeat denials, and faster payments.
For example, Alpha Medical and Behavioral Health reported fewer billing errors and faster reimbursements after working with A2Z Medical Billing Services.

Trustpilot Reviews

For practices that need support across claim submission, payment posting, and follow-up, A2Z’s medical billing services cover those parts of the revenue cycle.

Two Denial Management Lessons From A2Z’s Billing Team

Check each payer’s resubmission requirements and prioritize claims nearing their deadlines. These two practices help avoid repeat denials and missed payment opportunities.

1. Check the Payer’s Rules Before Resubmitting

Here’s a situation A2Z’s billing team described.

Say a commercial payer issues CO-16, and the accompanying remark information points to a modifier error. You fix the modifier and resubmit the claim, but leave out the original payer claim number.

The payer may reject the corrected claim or flag it as a duplicate because the required claim reference is missing.

This is why it’s important to check the submission rules even after correcting the original error.

For example, UnitedHealthcare’s corrected-claim guidance requires the appropriate replacement claim information, including the original payer claim number.

Original Medicare works differently for unprocessable claims. As discussed earlier, when an Original Medicare claim is returned with MA130, you generally need to correct the error and submit a new claim.

For billers: Fixing the error is only half the job. Make sure you’re following that payer’s rules for submitting the correction.

2. Work Claims With Approaching Deadlines First

When A2Z’s billing team has hundreds of claims to work through, they prioritize those getting close to their filing deadlines.

Think about it this way: a $250 claim with a deadline tomorrow may need your attention before a $1,000 claim that still has several weeks left.

For billing managers: Don’t prioritize claims by dollar amount alone. Consider how much time you have left to act, the potential reimbursement, and whether you’re dealing with an initial filing, corrected-claim, or appeal deadline.

Where to Find a Complete Medical Billing Denial Code List

For a complete claim denial codes list, use the official code sets maintained by X12.

The most useful references are:

You may also find a list of denial codes in medical billing as a PDF on other websites. Those can be helpful for quick reference, but check their publication dates.

Codes may be added, revised, or deactivated. For current billing decisions, use the official X12 lists and payer-specific instructions rather than relying entirely on an older downloadable chart.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the top 10 denials in medical billing?

Commonly encountered denial or adjustment codes include CO-16, CO-22, CO-27, CO-29, CO-50, CO-96, CO-97, CO-109, CO-204, and OA-18. They cover missing information, coverage problems, timely filing, medical necessity, bundling, and duplicate claims. This is a practical list, not a verified nationwide ranking.

What are all the denial codes in medical billing?

Medical billing uses claim adjustment group codes, CARCs, and RARCs to explain payment decisions. CO, PR, OA, and PI are the four current adjustment groups. The complete reason and remark code lists are maintained by X12.

What does CO 252 denial code mean?

CO-252 means additional documentation or an attachment is required to adjudicate the claim or service. Check the accompanying remark code to identify what’s missing, then submit the requested information through the payer’s required process.

How to find EOB denial code?

Open the EOB or ERA and locate the claim’s adjustment or reason-code section. Look for combinations such as CO-16 or PR-96, along with any accompanying remark codes. Match the adjustment to the correct service line before taking action.

How many denial codes are there in medical billing?

There isn’t one fixed number because the standardized code sets change over time. X12 maintains hundreds of Claim Adjustment Reason Codes and Remittance Advice Remark Codes, including active and deactivated entries.

What’s the difference between CO and PR denial codes?

CO identifies contractual obligations, generally amounts the provider cannot bill to the patient. PR identifies patient-responsibility adjustments such as deductibles, copays, and coinsurance. The amount collectible still depends on the plan, provider contract, and applicable laws.

Can a patient be billed for a CO denial?

Generally, no. CO adjustments are usually the provider’s responsibility under contractual or regulatory rules. Before transferring any denied balance to the patient, check the payer agreement, denial reason, and applicable patient billing protections.

What’s the difference between CARC and RARC?

A CARC explains why the payer adjusted a claim or service payment. A RARC gives additional information. For example, CARC 16 identifies a missing-information or submission problem, while RARC N290 points to the rendering provider’s primary identifier.

Conclusion

Understanding denial codes in medical billing helps your team identify payment problems, post adjustments correctly, and decide whether a claim needs correction, further review, or an appeal.

For a busy medical practice, having a consistent process for handling denials is just as important as knowing what the codes mean.

At A2Z Medical Billing Services, we help healthcare providers manage claim submission, payment posting, denial follow-up, and revenue cycle operations.

If recurring denials are delaying reimbursements or leaving unpaid claims sitting in accounts receivable, contact our billing team to discuss where your current billing process needs attention.

Need Reliable Medical Billing?

Talk to our experts about medical billing, insurance claims, revenue cycle management, and credentialing services.

Table of Contents

Free Billing Quote

Get A Free Practice Audit