While working with the remittance, you will see group codes CO, PR, OA, and PI as the two-letter codes preceding each adjustment. Group code CO indicates that the line has been written off by the provider. If the group code is PR, the amount is appropriate for billing the patient. The group code OA covers the adjustments other than the two preceding codes, while PI indicates a payment reduction from the payer. When reading the wrong groups, unnecessary amounts can be billed to the patients, or some amounts can be written off that can be collected later.
This guide illustrates each claim adjustment group code in simple words along with the correct interpretation of X12 and CMS. The guide goes on to elaborate on how the payers select the group, which CARC codes are limited to only one group, and what is allowed with Medicare, along with an explanation of how the different groups are priced and processed. The guide also provides a sample illustration of how the remittance is balanced accurately. If any reader is new to the reason and remark codes used, they need to go through the CARC vs RARC guide first.
What Are Claim Adjustment Group Codes?
A claim adjustment group code is a code that consists of two letters and specifies the type of adjustment, such as where this adjustment comes from. CMS mentions this group code in Chapter 22 of the Medicare Claims Processing Manual and specifies that this adjustment code should always appear next to the Claim Adjustment Reason Code (CARC).
When it comes to the 835 electronic remittance advice (ERA), the group code refers to CAS01, the first component of the CAS segment. As for the CARC, it comes in the next position, CAS02, and the amount comes in CAS03. So, if you see CO-45 or PR-2 on your report, you identify the letters as the group code, while the number is the CARC.
X12 provides a list of group codes. Currently, it contains four values: CO, OA, PI, and PR. There was another value which was CR (Correction and Reversal), but it is mentioned by X12 that CR should not be used from version 005010 onwards even though some remits carry it for older purposes. Thus, we can conclude that it should not be found in today’s ERAs as they are built on version 005010X221A1.
The four group codes at a glance
| Group code | Name | Who carries the amount | Common CARCs |
| CO | Contractual Obligation | Provider, under a contract or regulation | 45, 97, 16, 50, 197, 253 |
| PR | Patient Responsibility | Patient, or a secondary payer on the patient’s behalf | 1, 2, 3, 96, 204 |
| OA | Other Adjustment | Neither patient nor provider by default | 18, 23, 209 |
| PI | Payer Initiated Reductions | Provider, but not under a contract | 278, and payer-specific reductions |
CO: Contractual Obligation
CO refers to the agreement between you and the payer or a regulatory mandate, resulting in a write-off, so no fee is assessed to the patient. CMS uses this definition in Chapter 22, and CO adjustments are identified in the same manner in the CMS Blue Button code system.
The most common CO entry in any remit is CO-45, which denotes that the charge is higher than the allowed amount or the contracted amount. This is the usual write-off in the contract between your billed charge and the actual allowed charge. However, other CO adjustments are denials which you can often remedy.
CO-16: Claim lacks information or has a billing error. Fix the data and resubmit.
CO-97:The given service is a part of another pre-approved service. Ensure you examine the bundling changes.
CO-50: The payer does not consider it medically essential. Review the documentation and policy of coverage.
CO-197: Absence of prior approval, precertification, or notification was noted.
CO-253: sequestration, a reduction in federal payment.
CO refers to the agreement between you and the payer or a regulatory mandate, resulting in a write-off, so no fee is assessed to the patient. CMS uses this definition in Chapter 22, and CO adjustments are identified in the same manner in the CMS Blue Button code system. The most common CO entry in any remit is CO-45, which denotes that the charge is higher than the allowed amount or the contracted amount. This is the usual write-off in the contract between your billed charge and the actual allowed charge. However, other CO adjustments are denials, which you can often adjust.
PR: Patient Responsibility
PR means the adjusted amount may be billed to the patient or insured, or to another payer on the patient’s behalf. CMS names deductibles and copays as the typical PR amounts.
PR-1:
Deductible amount.
PR-2:
Coinsurance amount.
PR-3:
Co-payment amount.
PR-96 or PR-204:
Non-covered charges or a service not covered under the patient’s current benefit plan.
The guide 835 defines group code selection as an ordered process, while the patient responsibility question appears first. In the interpretation request No. 2048, X12 explained that the group code should be PR if the patient bears responsibility for the adjusted amount that is associated with a CARC. The important note is that the response is relevant to a submitter receiving coinsurance related to the CARC 2 under CO. X12 further explained that the guide does not connect CARC 1, 2, and 3 with the PR group code but rather obliges the remit to encode the entity responsible for making payment.
Medicare is very stern in this regard. There is an important alert, MA1,3, reminding providers that they may be penalized if they charge the patients amounts that are not reflected in the PR group code. Noridian provides examples that cannot be connected to the term PR, such as the penalties incurred because of late submission (CARC B4) and overcharges related to assigned claims (CARC 45).
PR amounts include cash only if they are collected. Our insurance verification services will provide information about deductibles, coinsurance, and copays before the visit, thus confirming the patient balance on the remit equals the initial estimate.
OA: Other Adjustment
OA is used only for adjustments when none of the other group codes can be used. The OA amount is not the responsibility of either the beneficiary or the provider under Medicare remit.
Several CARCs are locked to OA according to their X12 description:
- OA-18: claim or service is an exact duplicate. According to X12, CARC 18 is limited to OA unless state workers’ compensation rules mandate CO.
- OA-23: the previous payer’s adjustment impact, including payments and adjustments. You see it on secondary claims.
- OA-209: per regulatory or other agreement, the provider cannot collect this amount from the patient but can bill it to a subsequent payer.
An example given by Noridian is that a claim that is first adjudicated with CARC 23 paid in full is an OA adjustment because CARC 23 describes part of a payment and not a deduction from it. Also, OA-18 is quite common. First Coast Service Options listed OA-18 with RARC N522 as the most common Medicare Part B denial April26-June 26, 2026, and is recommending 14 to 29 days for claim processing before resubmission.
PI: Payer Initiated Reductions
PI refers to the determination by the payer that the adjustment is not the responsibility of the patient and that no agreement exists between payer and provider that would cover it. The CMS codes provide insight into how medical or professional reviews are addressed.
Typically, PI is issued by commercial publishers and also relates to compensatory and property payers. There are terms defined in Chapter 22 of Medicare. While there are some explicitly noted CARC codes with regard to PI, the #278 code speaks about the performance requirements that are not satisfied.
From a practical viewpoint, we can see that the PI amount that is subject to an adjustment is not the patient’s responsibility because there is no agreement that would stipulate the rules regarding the payment.
If you are out of network, and the No Surprises Act is applicable to you, the payer can send Out-of-Network Notification N830. It explains that the amounts held as OA, CO, or PI cannot be charged to the member, and any amount charged above the required amount must be returned to the patient.
How Group Codes Balance on a Remit: A Worked Example
As per the regulation by the CMS, which is explained in the 22nd chapter of their manual, the amount that gets paid should be equal to the billed amount after adjusting for other charges as well.
Paid amount = Billed charge – (CO + PR + OA + PI adjustments)
For example, let us say that the charge for a visit is $200. But as per the commercial plan, they only pay $120, and the patient has $40 as the remaining deductible with 20% coinsurance.
Sample service line, read group by group
| Adjustment | Math | Amount | Who owes it |
| CO-45 | $200.00 – $120.00 | $80.00 | Provider write-off |
| PR-1 | Remaining deductible | $40.00 | Patient |
| PR-2 | ($120.00 – $40.00) x 20% | $16.00 | Patient |
| Paid | $200.00 – $80.00 – $40.00 – $16.00 | $64.00 | Payer |
The figure in the answer shows $64.00 paid plus $136.00 in adjustments equals the $200.00 charge. The patient would be billed $56.00 ($40.00 + $16.00), while the rest would be written off as $80.00. In case the patient has a secondary agreement, the figure of $56.00 PR would be sent with the primary payer’s adjustments, and the secondary remit would show the mention of the primary’s adjustment as OA-23.
Now, let’s change. The payer had sent the codes CO-2 instead of PR-,2 and then the system would allow the writing off of the amount of $16.,00 which is wrong. The payer had sent CO-45 instead of PR-45; then the system would bill the patient for $80.00, which should be written off. Thus, you can see that the group code is processed first in the sequence.
Which CARCs Are Locked to One Group Code?
Some CARC descriptions name the only group codes they may be used with. If a remit pairs one of these CARCs with a different group, ask the payer to correct it before you post.
CARCs with a required group code
| CARC | What it means | Allowed group code |
| 18 | Exact duplicate claim or service | OA, except where state workers’ comp rules require CO |
| 23 | Impact of prior payer adjudication | OA only |
| 45 | Charge exceeds fee schedule or contracted amount | PR or CO, depending on liability |
| 85 | Patient interest adjustment | PR only |
| 209 | Provider cannot collect from patient, may bill a subsequent payer | OA only |
| 238 | Reduction for the ineligible period when a claim spans coverage | PR only |
| 249 | Claim identified as a readmission | CO only |
| 278 | Performance program proficiency requirements not met | CO or PI |
| 281 | Deductible waived per contractual agreement | CO only |
The rules are based on CARC definitions of the code found in the X12 list, which gets updated three times a year on roughly March 1, July 1, and November 1. Always consult the updated list before you set up posting rules based on them.
Common Group Code Mistakes and How to Fix Them
Most group code errors come from posting by CARC alone or trusting the payer’s group without checking it.
Group code mistakes, causes, and fixes
| What went wrong | Why it costs money | How to fix it |
| Patient billed for a CO amount | Contract violation, refunds and patient complaints; Medicare warns of penalties | Bill only PR amounts. Set your system so CO never moves to patient balance. |
| PR coinsurance sent as CO | You write off money the patient owes | Ask the payer to reprocess with PR, citing X12 RFI 2048. |
| CO-16 or CO-197 written off | Recoverable denials are lost | Route CO denials to correction or appeal before any write-off. |
| PI posted as contractual | Underpayments go unchallenged | Compare PI reductions to your contract and appeal mismatches. |
| OA-18 duplicate resubmitted again | More duplicates and delayed payment | Check claim status and wait for the original to finalize. |
| OA-23 ignored on secondaries | Secondary balance posted incorrectly | Post the primary’s payment and PR from the primary remit first. |
Group Code Posting Checklist
Post every adjustment by group code first, CARC second, and RARC third. Use this order on each service line:
- Confirm the line balances. Paid plus all adjustments must equal the billed charge.
- Post PR to the patient. Move PR-1, PR-,2 and PR-3 to patient balance or to the secondary payer.
- Separate CO-45 from CO denials. CO-45 is a contractual write-off. CO-16, CO-50, CO-97, CO-97, and CO-197 go to a work queue first.
- Review every PI line. Check the reduction against your contract and the payer’s policy.
- Check OA lines for duplicates and secondaries. Do not resubmit OA-18 claims, and match OA-23 to the primary remit.
- Flag group and CARC mismatches. A CARC locked to one group but sent with another goes back to the payer.
- Approve write-offs. No CO or PI amount is written off without a reviewer’s sign-off.
How A2Z Helps Practices Post and Work Group Codes
We post every adjustment by group code at the line level and send each one to the person who can act on it.
Line-level payment posting
Each CAS segment is posted to its service line with the group, CARC, and amount kept intact.
Routed to the right work queue
PR goes to patient billing, CO denials to correction or appeal, PI to contract review, and OA-18 to status checks.
Contract variance review
We compare CO-45 and PI reductions to your fee schedules, payer by payer, and you approve every write-off.
Clean patient statements
Only PR amounts reach patient statements. A2Z works inside your existing system with role-based access under a business associate agreement, so no migration is needed.
Frequently Asked Questions
What do the group codes CO, PR, O, A, and PI mean?
CO is Contractual Obligation, PR is Patient Responsibility, OA is Other Adjustment, and PI is Payer Initiated Reductions. Each one tells you who carries the amount the payer did not pay.
Can I bill the patient for a CO adjustment?
No. CO amounts are the provider’s responsibility under a contract or regulation, and Medicare says the beneficiary may not be billed for them.
What is the difference between CO and PI?
Neither is the patient’s to pay. CO comes from a contract or regulation, while PI is a payer reduction with no contract behind it, so PI is worth checking for underpayment.
Does Medicare use the PI group code?
Medicare’s Claims Processing Manual defines only CO, OA, and PR for Medicare remits. PI shows up mostly on commercial, workers’ compensation, and property and casualty remits.
What does OA-23 mean on a secondary claim?
OA-23 reports the impact of the prior payer’s adjudication, including its payment and adjustments. X12 limits CARC 23 to the OA group.
What does CO-45 mean?
CO-45 means the billed charge exceeds the fee schedule or contracted amount, and the difference is a contractual write-off for the provider.
Is the CR group code still used?
Not on current ERAs. X12 says CR is not to be used with version 005010 and later, which is the HIPAA-adopted 835 version.
Where is the group code on an 835 file?
It is CAS01, the first element of the CAS segment, followed by the CARC in CAS02 and the amount in CAS03.
Get Every Group Code Posted and Worked Correctly
Submit a set of recent ERAs to us, and we can provide you with a picture of incorrectly entered COs, PIs, and PRs and their values. You can either start with denial management services or check our CARC vs. RARC guide to know the codes related to each group.